How does a Restructuring Plan differ from a CVA?
A CVA can only bind unsecured creditors and can be defeated by 25% of voting creditors by value. A Restructuring Plan can involve both secured and unsecured creditors, and can be imposed on dissenting classes through cross-class cram down if the court is satisfied the conditions are met. It is a more powerful tool, but also more expensive and procedurally demanding.
What is the 75% rule in a Restructuring Plan?
For a class of creditors to be treated as having approved the plan, at least 75% in value of those who vote must vote in favour. Unlike a scheme of arrangement, there is no requirement for a majority by number — only by value.
What is the "relevant alternative"?
The relevant alternative is what would happen to the company if the Restructuring Plan were not sanctioned — typically liquidation. At the sanction hearing, the court must be satisfied that no member of a dissenting class is any worse off under the plan than they would be in that alternative. This is the legal test for cross-class cram down.
Is a Restructuring Plan expensive?
Yes — it involves two court hearings, significant legal input, and detailed financial modelling of the relevant alternative. It is generally most appropriate for mid-market or larger companies with complex debt structures where the cross-class cram down is essential to the rescue. For smaller businesses, a CVA or moratorium is likely to be more cost-effective.
Can small businesses use a Restructuring Plan?
While the procedure is technically available to all companies, its cost makes it prohibitive for most smaller businesses. There is a separate Small Business Restructuring process designed specifically for smaller companies with simpler debt profiles. We can advise quickly on which procedure is most appropriate for your size and situation.
Is my company eligible?
To qualify, your company must be facing, or be likely to face, financial difficulties that affect its ability to carry on as a going concern. The plan must be designed to eliminate, reduce, or mitigate those difficulties. There is no minimum size requirement, but the cost structure means it is rarely proportionate below a certain scale of debt complexity.